As someone who cannot live without lip balm, I feel qualified to rate any of them! Tui Lip Balm is "The Bomb", and I usually have a couple of pots around, one next to the bed and one somewhere else. I love to have the contrast of the Vanilla flavour and the Spearmint. The pots are brilliant value, and buying NZ made is a no-brainer! (Buy NZ - always!). The pots are better value than the sticks, but to be fair, I have one waiting to go once I finish my Antipodes one! (Also highly recommend their Insect Repellant Balm).