Not for me
I was disappointed by the smell - it smelt like a lime lolly. Also it left my clothes smelling unpleasant around the armpits.
I really wanted to love this, as I had tried a sample of the other fragrance, which also smelt kinda gross, but did work surprisingly well.
Also, the shape of the large square isn't really that handy for under armpits. Maybe better if it came in two rectangles (square cut in half) instead?
Please ethique - get the smell right! Your two fragrances smell pretty artifical to me, more like room freshner.
If you get a nice fragrance, then I would like to try again.